The following is an excerpt from Celia Millward and Jane Flick, Handbook for Writers, Canadian Edition (Toronto: Holt, Rinehart and Winston of Canada, Ltd., 1985), pp. 344–345.
Every paper should have a title, which should specify or at least suggest the contents of the paper. A good title is more specific than simply a description of the general subject area of the paper. That is, if your instructor has assigned a paper on cheating in schools, your title should not be simply “Cheating in Schools.” To avoid overly general titles, it is best to postpone deciding on a title until after you have formulated a thesis statement or, even better, until after you have written your first draft.
Titles should not be long; if you title takes up more than one line on the page, try to shorten it. For example, “A Description of the Old Open-Air Market in Kitchener” can easily be shortened to “Kitchener’s Open-Air Market.” Catchy titles are appealing to the reader but are more appropriate for informal or humorous topics than for serious topics. In any case, don’t spend a great deal of time trying to think of a catchy title; a straightforward descriptive title is always acceptable.
…
Although a good title does not necessarily reveal the rhetorical type of a paper, it does provide an indication of it. Listed below are three broad subject areas. Possible titles are given for papers in each subject area and for each rhetorical type.
SUBJECT AREA | RHETORICAL TYPE | PAPER TITLE |
tobacco | exposition | How To Roll Your Own Cigarettes |
argument | Why Snuff Should Replace Cigarettes | |
description | The Parphernalia of a Pipe-Smoker | |
narration | My First Encounter with Chewing Tobacco | |
automobiles | exposition | Developing a Nonpolluting Engine |
argument | Teen-agers Make the Best Drivers | |
description | My New Datsun 200 SX | |
narration | Tragedy on the Trans-Canada | |
fires | exposition | Arson: The Fastest-Growing Crime |
argument | Smoke Detectors Are Worthless | |
description | Our House After the Fire | |
narration | The Great London Fire of 1666 |