A man (Calum Carmichael, Editor with "PANL Perspectives") smiles at the camera.By Calum Carmichael (part of our ongoing series, “Building a Stronger Culture of Philanthropy in Canada“).

For the first ten years of Carleton University’s MPNL program, I delivered the introductory course. So, for old time’s sake, I’d like to distribute a take-home assignment – one you can complete either on your own or in a group — an assignment that will shed more light on how the media represents philanthropy and how it shapes our norms:

  1. Consider the following proposition: “The mainstream media portray philanthropy as something practiced by certain types of people with whom many Canadians can’t readily identify.”
  2. Now, bearing that proposition in mind, the next time you come across philanthropy in the mainstream media – or social media, for that matter – think about who’s being portrayed as practicing it. See what you come up with.
A man in a suit stands and smiles at the camera.

The mainstream media often portrays philanthropists who are extremely wealthy, heroic or who benefit from tax advantages that come from charitable giving.

From a totally superficial, unscientific media review (i.e., an online word search of “philanthropy” in articles published over the past year by The Globe and Mail) – whom did I come across as the featured practitioners? Not surprisingly, they were ones deemed “newsworthy”: the very wealthy, the heroic and accomplished, the serious and self-sacrificial, or those deemed to have a passion for a particular cause or institution or even a particular grudge. The broadest category I came across was of people being advised at year’s end of the tax advantages that could come from well-managed charitable giving. The “sponsored content” that dealt with philanthropy appeared even more exclusive: in addition to the above, the accompanying visuals suggested one also had to be beautiful.

Sure enough, many of the newsworthy practitioners struck me as commendable. Nevertheless, they also struck me as offering few role models with which most people could readily identify – people, for example, who don’t think of themselves as especially wealthy, heroic or self-sacrificial; or people who don’t find themselves passionate about any particular cause, resentment or institution, let alone the particular ones being featured. For them, philanthropy as portrayed would remain something done by people different from themselves.

The media, whether mainstream or social, can both reflect and shape a society’s priorities, beliefs and behaviour. Admittedly, by presenting philanthropy as exceptional and newsworthy, the mainstream media may be reflecting Canada’s currently spotty – indeed, I’d say fraying – culture of philanthropy. But they may be shaping and perpetuating that culture as well.

Most of the pieces composing our series on building a stronger culture of philanthropy in Canada focus on certain groups or communities in which philanthropy – at least as it applies to our willingness to help – remains relatively active. Across those pieces – of faith communities, Indigenous communities, women with greater agency and money, or multicultural communities including new Canadians – I’ve picked up an underlying theme: a person’s identity can serve as a driver of philanthropic behaviour, as in “I give of my time and financial resources because that’s part of who I am, that’s part of what defines both me and the communities with which I affiliate.” If that’s the case, then one of the ways to strengthen and broaden our culture of philanthropy would be to strengthen and broaden such an identity across all Canadians.

Prime Minister Carney’s September 2026 video address – as noted and quoted earlier in this series by Susan Phillips – touched on this point: “It’s about making Canada strong, and the compassion that makes us who we are.” A compassion, I’d add, that ideally would encourage and normalize our personal and collective responsibility for empathy and action: empathy that involves our regard for those in need and those with whom we differ; and action that involves our learning about those needs and differences, together with our assisting or defending the people at hand.

As individuals we can’t override the media’s portrayal of philanthropy and its practitioners. But we, as non-newsworthy Canadians who take philanthropy seriously and seek to practice it daily, can nevertheless speak of and serve as examples of the well-being that can come of it – whether for ourselves, for those we help or defend, for our sense of community, or even more broadly for our social cohesion and democratic resilience as a nation. That message – whether we convey it in person or on social media – isn’t about us. We’re not the focus. It’s about what we and Canadians like us can do.

Read Calum Carmichael’s thought piece, “Why We Should Build a Stronger Culture of Philanthropy,” part of our ongoing Culture of Philanthropy series.

Monday, November 16, 2026 in
Share: Twitter, Facebook