Digital Fundraising in Canadian Charities: What’s Working, What’s Next, and What’s Holding Us Back
Since the Covid-19 pandemic, digital technology has dramatically reshaped the fundraising landscape for charities worldwide. The McKinsey Global Survey estimates that the pandemic accelerated business digital adoption by nearly seven years – a shift that charities cannot afford to ignore.
Our CICP surveys show that digital fundraising is now one of the top needed skills across the Canadian charitable sector, both for new hires (CICP 1.01.04) and for existing staff (CICP 2.05.17). Yet implementation still lags behind: just 19% of organizations ran targeted email campaigns, 14% used social media fundraising, and only 5% tried crowdfunding (CICP 2.06.21).
In this post, we’ll explore how charities can make the most of digital fundraising – even on a tight budget. Drawing on expert advice from Michael Johnston and Mackenzie West (2022), we’ll highlight key principles that remain timeless in the digital age, practical tactics for various digital platforms, and emerging trends that fundraisers should keep on their radar.
Timeless Fundraising Principles That Also Work Digitally
Even in the digital age, the core principles of effective fundraising haven’t changed – just the ways we deliver them. Here are five best practices that Johnston and West (Canada) recommend: multichannel conversion, audience segmentation, fundraising copyrighting, integrated messaging, and what is in it for me?
These five fundraising principles are evident in these examples:
| Tools or Tactics | Summary | Example(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Most cost-effective and versatile method for storytelling and solicitations. | Animal welfare campaign via email; direct links to donation page. | |
| Top social media platform for fundraising, especially among older demographics. | Greater Vancouver Food Bank’s monthly donor campaign – 90 new donors, ROI 7:1. | |
| Lightboxes | Pop-up tool for urgent messages on websites, great for emergency fundraising. | Old Ottawa South Community Association raised $10,806 in 3 weeks. |
| Crowdfunding | Organic supporter-led campaigns via platforms like GoFundMe or Kickstarter; best for one-time or short-term projects; reward-based approach works better. | George Floyd donations on GoFundMe; social justice campaigns engaging young and diverse donors. |
| Website design | Optimizing layout and calls-to-action for better donation conversion. | Children’s Health Foundation: +76% online revenue, +23% web traffic. |
| GIFs | Quick-moving visuals to grab attention and convey urgency | Used in countdowns, match campaigns, emergency appeals |
| Video | Personal, low-cost storytelling tool for donor engagement | Thank-you videos for donors from clients (e.g. Canada’s National Ballet School); YouTube seminars |
| Blogging | Content-based donor engagement via regular website updates | Charities using blogs to share impact stories and deepen donor connection |
| 50/50 Lotteries | Fundraiser where half the proceeds go to donors as prize money | COVID-era rise in participation; subject to provincial gaming laws |
| SMS Text | Emergency-focused direct ask with links to donate via text | Animal welfare orgs raising funds for specific animals in urgent care |
| Influencer marketing | Partnering with social media influencers to raise funds | Home décor influencers with lotteries (e.g., Full House Lottery in Alberta) |
| Online gaming | Using livestreaming and gaming tournaments to engage youth donors | Camp Quality Rocket League tournament; Twitch charity streams |
| Google Ad Grants | Free digital advertising to boost visibility and traffic | Up to $10,000/month in ads; only 37% of orgs currently using it |
| Digital Surveys | Used to learn donor preferences and improve personalization | Post-donation surveys on email to optimize communication |
| Big Gifts via Digital | Digital channels prompting legacy or asset-based donations | Vic Foundation: 12% of surveyed donors expressed intent to leave legacy gifts |
What’s Ahead for Digital Fundraising and What’s Holding Us Back?
While no one can predict the next big platform or tool, several trends are already reshaping how charities connect with donors – and many organizations are beginning to take notice.
First, smarter use of data is on the horizon. CICP survey reports a growing interest in AI-powered data analysis, which nearly half of Canadian charities (48%) say they would like to explore (CICP 3.05.16). Charities also report that the top future needs for digital transformation include data management, CRM systems, digital marketing, and AI integration (CICP 2.06.23)
Second, automation is gaining momentum. Beyond simple thank-you emails, tools can now run personalized campaigns across email, social media, and websites. Many charities already see the promise of AI and automation in fundraising-related activities such as grant writing and marketing where support rose from 68% in 2023 to 75% in 2024 (CICP 1.10.42; CICP 2.10.39).
Yet, barriers to digital fundraising remain. Many leadership teams have hesitated to commit to long-term digital strategies: only 11% of Canadian charities report having a digital strategic plan – a stark contrast to 50% in the UK (CICP 2.04.12). Funding limitations affect three-quarters of charities, while skill shortages and lack of training access remain a barrier for 43% (CICP 2.04.12). Our findings confirm what Michael Johnston and Mackenzie West emphasize: the main roadblocks to digital fundraising are not tools, but the skills development and budgetary priorities.
Author
Want to receive our blog posts directly to your email? Sign-up for our newsletter at the following link, and follow us on social-media for regular project updates:
- Newsletter sign up: https://confirmsubscription.com/h/t/3D0A2E268835E2F4
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/cicp-pcpob/
- Socials: @CICP_PCPOB
5 min read
Technology, Human Spirit, and the Ethics of Progress: Charities and AI
5 min read
Stable on Paper, Strained in Practice: The Workforce Crisis in Canadian Charities
4 min read