I must commend the Hon. Minister Boudreau for recognizing the need to address issues of population health in New Brunswick (behind a paywall, sorry). This province has some of the highest rates of chronic disease in Canada, high rates of obesity, and high rates of smoking (see Statistics Canada). Overall, New Brunswick does not fare well in health as compared to the rest of Canada. Part of this is history (it takes a long time for generational change to occur), part is demographic (we are aging faster and youth are leaving), but a large part is structural (Social Determinants).
Briefly, the social determinants of health are those factors influence the overall health of populations, as opposed to individuals. These factors include income; education; social support networks (community); working conditions; social environments; built and natural environments; personal health practices; healthy child development; gender; and culture. Much has been written on these determinants, and many public servants within the Government of New Brunswick are keenly aware of how addressing determinants “upstream” can improve the health of the population much more than individual-level behavioural changes.
In his comments, Minister Boudreau makes a start in addressing social determinants, by noting that poverty, education, and social support play a role in health. He also recognizes that a “comprehensive approach” is required. However, at the same time he places the blame on the individual for “sitting in front of our iPads” or “drinking a lot of water.” These small choices are not aspects that the government can or should address, and do more to demonize people for relaxing with technology or choosing a tea over a glass of water.
A comprehensive strategy by government would begin with a horizontal consistency across policies – which would require a whole new approach to governing. For example, when fuel prices begin to rise there are inevitable calls for a rebate program. However, subsidizing vehicular travel works directly against efforts to get people out of their cars more, to make shorter and fewer trips. Our communities are designed around the vehicle with streetscapes oriented to allow for the efficient movement of cars. What about making our communities denser, making pedestrians the focus of our communities? This can happen in places large and small (See NB’s own Hassan Arif for some ideas).
Eduction is another area where there is a lack of policy consistency. School days are shorter in New Brunswick and students have fewer in-class days than in other provinces (especially after snow days). At the same time, the introduction of new standardized testing requires teachers to spend more time teaching to the test rather than allowing for free-play and physical activity time. Children are thus more sedentary throughout the day, have more trouble paying attention in class, our readiness for university is lower, and so on.. These are all parts of the social determinants of health.
There are many people in New Brunswick who know a lot about this topic, publish on this topic, and suggest policies on this topic. Minister Boudreau can look at great organizations such as the New Brunswick Health Research Foundation or the New Brunswick Social Policy Research Network that work within the Province and host many dedicated and knowledgeable researchers. We don’t need to “come together” anymore to discuss ideas, many ideas are already here and already have evidence. We need some real policies based on evidence that are implemented with the health of people in mind.